The Winning M&A Advisor [Vol. 1, Issue 4]
Welcome to the 4th issue of the Winning M&A Advisor, the Axial publication that anonymously unpacks data, fees, and terms…
Tags
There is a reason why it’s called “exit planning” and not simply “exiting” – the steps involved in determining how to ultimately leave the company you’ve built require careful thought, deliberate consideration, and plenty of time.
A good place to start is often with the end in mind. By first identifying the ideal outcome of your exit, you will be able to determine the best partner for the transition. For context, here are 6 of the most likely groups to buy your business, as well as some information about what a sale to each implies.
One of the most likely buyers of a company is actually another company. The businesses that pursue growth through acquisition are often referred to as “strategic buyers.” This name is bestowed because the companies look for acquisition targets that are aligned with their core strategy, rather than other characteristics of a company, like financial metrics.
One advantage of selling to a strategic buyer is that your business might command a higher sale price. Strategics will often pay a premium for the synergies that make your business a natural fit alongside their own.
Typically, however, the higher acquisition price can come at a cost. Synergies often accompany redundancies between the two companies that may be eliminated during the merger or acquisition. By selling to a strategic, you might be risking the jobs of employees in departments that overlap from company to company (like accounting, human resources, and marketing). In addition, the brand and identity you’ve worked to build for your business may be absorbed by that of a competitor.
As a result, selling to a corporation is ideal for business owners looking for a lucrative exit, where the future direction of the company and its employees is not the primary concern.
Private equity firms are investment vehicles for institutional investors or high net-worth individuals. Limited partners (“LPs”) invest their money into funds that general partners (“GPs”) of the PE firm use to buy companies, typically within a specific industry. PE executives seek to maximize the growth of the portfolio companies over 5-7 years before selling them and earning a return for themselves and their investors.
PE executives bring the financial resources and the corporate acumen to take your operations to the next level, and in many cases they will retain company owners and operators for on-the-ground expertise, making them a great option if you’d prefer to retain a piece of your equity stake. Selling to a PE firm is a great way to help your business realize its full potential.
Given the nature of their funds, however, private equity firms are usually looking to maximize the profitability of your business in the short-term. This overarching thesis will inform a lot of the decisions they make for your business.
Family offices resemble private equity firms in some respects, but they differ in important ways. Rather than acting as investment vehicles for groups of high net worth individuals and institutional investors, family offices invest the money of a single wealthy family, typically with a focus on the industry that netted that family its fortune. Family offices’ primary objective is ensuring that familial wealth spans multiple generations.
As a result, as compared to private equity firms, family offices tend to hold more conservative portfolios, invest on longer time horizons, and take far less active roles in their portfolio companies.
However, family offices are scarce and difficult to reach. Since they invest with only cash (and not debt), the sale prices they offer are usually lower than their PE or strategic counterparts. Family offices are ideal for the business owner looking for industry guidance and/or direction.
Holding companies (aka shell companies) exist primarily for the sole purpose of owning other companies. Typically they do not sell any products or services of their own. Instead, they generate revenue from the dividends and earnings of the stock they own in other businesses. The most famous example is Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway.
Holding companies often seek a controlling stake in the companies under their umbrella, which means that while selling part or all of your business to a holding company can be a relatively simple way to cash in equity. However, the additional support brings more cooks into the kitchen; instead of running the business solo, you have to confer with new members of the board. Keep in mind also that, while holding companies owned by others might make good buyers, there can be tax benefits in certain instances to forming your own holding company as part of your sale process.
If the idea of managing a sale primarily through an individual is appealing, then exploring search funds can be a great option. Search funds consist typically of an individual, backed by a team of investors, looking to buy a business and take over the operations.
Oftentimes, that individual is a recent MBA graduate who aspires to operating a business. His team of investors is willing to buy the company for him to operate, confident that he will generate a return with their guidance. While this scenario involves a “green” buyer and any associated risks, it can nevertheless be a great way to ensure the long-term vitality of your business by infusing the C-suite with youth and energy. If you’d like to see your business continue on without you and you are willing to bet on ambition, then selling to a search fund is a great option.
Selling to new parties — like the above options — can welcome some measure of change on the direction and/or operations of your business once ownership is transferred. If you’re looking for an exit opportunity that allows your company to maintain its current course in your absence, look no further than your employees. An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) will gradually transfer the company’s equity into retirement packages for your employees, while a leveraged ESOP provides the employees with debt to buy the owner out of a portion, if not all, of his equity up front. ESOPs provide employees with valuable measures of input and control, but they also add administrative hurdles that can slow future development.
Again, this is a process you should take your time with – even if you have no timetable by which you’d like to sell your business, it can be helpful just to understand what types of buyers gravitate towards businesses like yours. To take a look at some of the buyers who suit you, and to discuss your options with an experienced advisor, log in to your Axial account or join the network for free today.